Pdf capital structure arbitrage under a riskneutral. A price discovery perspective, published in the spring 2020 issue of the journal of alternative investments, davide avino university of liverpool emese lazar university of reading create a price discovery filter for trades in a capital structure arbitrage strategy csa, and two similar but unhedged trading strategies. Capital structure arbitrage is an investment strategy that seeks to take advantage of disparities between different equities and debt products issued by the same company. The apt relates the expected rate of return on a sequence of primitive securities to their factor sensitivities, suggesting that factor risk is of critical importance in asset pricing gilles and leroy, 1990. Its objective is to profit from the pricing inefficiency in the issuing firms capital structure with the expectation that the pricing disparity between the two securities will cancel out converge. It assumes that both markets instantaneously react to new information, so it fails to take into account the leadlag relationships between the prices in the two markets and their form of cointegration. However, both the volatilityvariance swaps and cds have a lower liquidity at the single name level but similar analysis can be extended to portfolio products in credit and equity, which are highly liquid. The arbitrage pricing theory apt was developed primarily by ross 1976a, 1976b. It requires less and more realistic assumptions to be generated by a simple arbitrage argument and its explanatory power is potentially better since it is a multifactor model. Apr 15, 1997 it needs to be emphasized that the no arbitrage condition is not only sufficient but also necessary for the validity of the asset pricing formula. Divergence between the synthetic and the traded cds can still occur, as sentiment may differ between the equity and credit markets for a given company. The latter are bonds that are, under contractedfor conditions, convertible into shares of equity.
Regulatory capital arbitrage opportunities under the. Fixed income arbitrage oxfordman institute of quantitative. Capital structure arbitrage mentions to trading strategies that take advantage of the relative mispricing across different securities traded on the same capital structure. As the exponential growth in the credit default swap cds market has made credit much. There are numerous extensions to structural arbitrage. Steve has to figure out which trades to put on to exploit the potential mispricing and what the main profit drivers of this strategy are.
We shall display that the main driver of the arbitrage strategy must be to trade the cds against. Investment strategy in which an undervalued security is bought and the same firms overvalued security is sold. The arbitrage theory of capital asset pricing stephen a. The profitability of capital structure arbitrage has been discussed in previous studies. Evidence from equity lending markets melissa porras pradoy pedro a. Capital structure arbitrage the capital structure of a company consists of its assets which are the sum of its debt and equity. Such a necessity condition is surprisingly absent in the apt literature. The travails in the industry were naturally reflected in the. Page 3 of 4 portfolio construction market and credit assessment lead directly to the construction of the portfolio. The fragile capital structure of hedge funds and the limits to arbitrage xuewen liuy antonio s.
Capital structure arbitrage capital structure arbitrage outline. Managers look for a relative value between the senior and junior securities of the. The capital structure decisions of new firms alicia m. Arbitrage, factor structure, and meanvariance analysis on. This website uses cookies to distinguish you from other users. When implemented correctly, it is the practice of being able to take a positive and. According to alifani and nugroho 20 firms find it convenient to have the debt in their capital structure due to the tax shield effect, which consequently means that they pay less tax. Your story matters citation chamberlain, gary, and michael j. In 1976 ross introduced the arbitrage pricing theory apt as an alternative to the capm. Limited arbitrage between equity and credit markets. Apr 03, 2018 sears 2018 senior secured and 2019 senior unsecured bonds are currently trading for 68 cents and 28 cents on the dollar respectively, because of looming bankruptcy fears. The former consists of capital, reserves and term loans raised from public and financial institutions, while the latter is made up of current.
Also, the market value of a bond will always approach its par value as maturity is approached. The analysis uses the creditgrades benchmark model, a convergencetype trading strategy, and 5,759 daily cds. A recent study by jarrow et al 2018, 19 focused on statistical arbitrages in the cds term structure by identifying mispricing of cdss based on. Euromoney december 2002 antony currie and jennifer morris go to our specialist pages on markets and products and regions. Capital structure arbitrage with a nongaussian asset model abstract capital structure arbitrage refers to the practice of exploiting relative pricing inefficiencies in the market by taking long and short positions across different instruments and asset classes of the capital structure of the same firm. No arbitrage pricing and the term structure of interest rates. Capital structure arbitrage northwestern university. It is a oneperiod model in which every investor believes that the stochastic properties of returns of capital assets are consistent with a factor structure.
The fragile capital structure of hedge funds and the. Search for related euromoney publications and events markets have crushed banks this year but now some see a profit to be made in arbitraging debt against equity. Benson durham federal reserve bank of new york staff reports, no. This paper conducts a comprehensive analysis of the risk and return of capital structure arbitrage using cds data on 221 north american obligors in 2002 to 2004.
This document was created with prince, a great way of getting web content onto paper. Pdf by reinterpreting the calibration of structural models, a reassessment of the importance of the input variables is undertaken. You go long the stock, and then you hedge with singlename credit protection the only way you can effectively go short the debt. If capital structure is irrelevant in a perfect market, then imperfections which exist in the real world must be the cause of its relevance. March 2011 1nikunj kapadia and xiaoling pu are from the university of massachusetts and kent state univer sity, respectively.
Saffiz jason sturgessx march 15th, 20 abstract we examine how institutional ownership structure gives rise to limits to arbitrage through its. Ownership structure, limits to arbitrage, and stock returns. An empirical investigation of arbitrage pricing theory. This presentation clarifies the difference between traditional and certain non traditional cdo capital structure arbitrage. November 2012 abstract it is well known that the capital structure arbitrage strategy generated negative sharpe ratios over the period 20052009. Capital structure arbitrage 3 how efficient are credit. Consider, for example, traditional bonds, and convertible bonds. Mar 28, 2020 capital structure arbitrage is an investment strategy that seeks to take advantage of disparities between different equities and debt products issued by the same company. It exploits different prices of long duration bonds and vix etfs, which can both be used as substitutions for equity hedging. In their words, the market value of any firm is independent of its capital structure and is given by capitalizing its expected return at the rate appropriate to its risk class. An empirical study of capital structure arbitrage based on. There is a significant relationship between capital structure and their total market value in the stock exchange thailand. Capital structure arbitrage involves taking long and short positions in di. Master thesis capital structure arbitrage strategies.
Its no surprise that they should be pioneers, given that their core product itself is a hybrid of debt and equity. Using the url or doi link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely. Arbitrage free bond prices can be found simply from the fact that these are assets with a nite life and a xed redemption value. The multiple strategies of hedge funds investopedia. Ross departments of economics and finance, university of pennsylvania, the wharton school, philadelphia, pennsylvania 19174 received march 19, 1973.
The first hedge funds to get involved were those specializing in convertible arbitrage. Theories of capital structure explained with examples. Arbitrage, factor structure, and meanvariance analysis on large asset markets gary chamberlain, michael rothschild. Capital structure arbitrage, similar to eventdriven trades, also underlies most hedge fund credit strategies. Structural arbitrage this strategy was implemented to verify some ideas of harry long i read on seeking alpha. The market permits no arbitrage opportunities if and only if for any portfolio p, vp cp 0 implies ep 0. Capital structure arbitrage refers to trading strategies that take advantage of the relative mispricing across di. Capital structure arbitrage and hedging involves taking long and short positions in di. Mello hkust wisconsin school of business forthcoming in journal of financial economics abstract during a nancial crisis, when investors are most in need of liquidity and accurate prices, hedge funds cut their arbitrage positions and hoard cash. Practical applications of rethinking capital structure. Credit opportunities strategy columbia threadneedle.
Sears capital structure creates arbitrage opportunity. At the same time, he needs to be aware of the risks of his strategy and whether the mispricing could be attributable to factors that his capital structure arbitrage. View test prep capital structure arbitrage 3 from finance 411 at university of michigan. Capital structure arbitrage with a nongaussian asset model. A no arbitrage analysis of economic determinants of the credit spread term structure numerous empirical studies, mostly based on regression analysis, show that the frequency of credit events and the expected loss from such events depend crucially on the state. The capital structure decision can affect the value of the firm either by changing the expected earnings or the cost of capital or both. The fragile capital structure of hedge funds and the limits. Model choice and volatility calibration july, 2008. It is considered to be an alternative to the capital asset pricing model as a method to explain the returns of portfolios or assets. A noarbitrage analysis of economic determinants of the credit spread term structure numerous empirical studies, mostly based on regression analysis, show that the frequency of credit events and the expected loss from such events depend crucially on the state of the macroeconomy and the.
Posts about capital structure arbitrage written by memyselfandi007. Arbitrage, factor structure, and meanvariance analysis on large asset markets. Furthermore, we exhibit the practical relevance and assumptions of these models. Arbitrage pricing theory assumptions explained hrf. Our public strategies should be starting points for further investigation.
The apt has the potential to overcome capms weaknesses. Aug 17, 2014 structural arbitrage can be implemented with midterm volatility. Treasury term premiums and the term structure of equity risk premiums. Capital structure arbitrage value and opportunity page 2. Download this paper open pdf in browser add paper to my library. When identifying relative value opportunities across credit and equity markets, the arbitrageur faces two major problems, namely positions based on model misspeci cation and mismeasured inputs. Arbitrage is the simultaneous purchase and sale of an asset to profit from a difference in the price. G21,g24,l26 abstract this paper investigates the capital structure choices that firms make in their initial year of operation, using restrictedaccess data from the kauffman firm survey.
Fundamentals of global strategy a business model approach. Arbitrage, factor structure, and meanvariance analysis on large asset markets the harvard community has made this article openly available. Profit of their trading strategy was very modest, far less pronounced than. Saffiz jason sturgessx abstract we examine how institutional ownership structure gives rise to limits to arbitrage through. The stock market is deep and liquid enough that you can buy your shares without moving the market. But even their shift from pure convertible plays into capital structure arbitrage was more by accident than by design. Capital asset pricing model and arbitrage pricing theory. A noarbitrage analysis of economic determinants of the. As i was trying to research a little bit how to value a pipeline of drugs still in development actelion spinoff, i stumbled across the socalled contingent value rights cvrs which are often used in pharma takeovers. A trader believes that debt of a company is under priced trader purchases the cheap corporate bonds hedges his position by purchasing puts on the stocks no default receives yield on bond in excess of what he paid for put option default. Capital structure arbitrage refers to the practice of exploiting relative pricing inefficiencies in the market by taking long and short positions across different instruments and asset classes of the capital structure of the same firm. The capitalassetpricing model and arbitrage pricing theory.
In this article we will discuss about the capital structure and value of firm. Fan yu the article examines the risk and return of capital structure arbitrage, which exploits the mispricing between a companys credit default swap cds spread and equity price. Nontraditional capital structure arbitrage transactions. Trading a corporates equity against its debt is the basic technique of capital structure arbitrage. When looking at one security in order to signal the sale or purchase of. There are no arbitrage opportunities in the economy. Capital structure arbitrage under a riskneutral calibration. The objective of the firm should be directed towards the maximization of the value of the firm the capital structure, or average, decision should be examined from the point of view of its impact on the value of the firm. I will use the word to describe any arbitrage free model in which bond yields are af.
Ownership structure, limits to arbitrage and stock returns. Arbitrage, factor structure, and mean variance analysis. Pdf capital structure arbitrage with a nongaussian. Capital structure arbitrage how is capital structure. A firm mobilizes funds which, depending upon their maturity period, can be classified as longterm and shortterm sources. Mms arbitrage argument is based on the following assumptions. The thematic core portfolio is constructed with a bias to. In general, capital structure arbitrage strategies can be viewed as an example of. The capital structure decisions of new firms nber working. Are there any optimal capital structure of firms in stock exchange thailand and to examine for the relationship between capital structure and company value. Capital structure chapter 15 and chapter 16 contents i. The capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage pricing theory. As most anyone who hasnt had their head in the sand the past couple years will tell you, it is a terrible time to be a coal miner.
Aug 01, 2012 which sets up an easy and obvious capitalstructure arbitrage. The capital structure arbitrage strategy exploits the discrepancies between the credit default swap and equity markets. The optimal structure would be to have virtually no equity at all, i. Capital structure arbitrage is a strategy in which a firms under valued security is bought and the same firms overvalued security is sold. Investors using the strategy will spot such a disparity and then buy or sell assets based on the logical assumption that the market will correct the disparity. Abstract this paper examines the risk and return of the socalled. Capital structure and value of firm financial management. G10, g12, g, g15 abstract a small but ambitious literature uses affine arbitrage free models to estimate jointly u.
Limited arbitrage between equity and credit markets nikunj kapadia and xiaoling pu1 first version. Rethinking capital structure arbitrage davide avino and emese lazar icma centre, university of reading, henley school of business, po box 242 rg6 6ba, uk current version. Also, neither of the strategies hold significantly positive alpha after accounting for fees. This helps us to provide you with a good user experience and also allows us to improve our website. The chapter shows that no matter how you cut up the financial claims to. Risk in capital structure arbitrage london business school. It is a trade that profits by exploiting the price differences of identical or similar. Fixed income arbitrage broad set of marketneutral strategies intended to exploit valuation differences between various fixed income securities swap spread arbitrage yield curve arbitrage mortgage arbitrage volatility arbitrage capital structure arbitrage. The chapter shows that no matter how you cut up the financial claims to the firm sold in the capital markets, the real.
1585 1294 142 792 994 192 560 1161 691 1210 778 853 946 1421 1276 1565 927 515 912 1393 1527 421 1194 1257 1281 386 1248 698 942 1375 539 1035 830 1543 146 1617 923 605 1222 1171 296 230 34 1241 871